If I make it (already playing around with permissions so more than likely it'll happen), it will be open for the public to view but gatekept to where only people selected will be able to post and use it normally. Think of it as a reverse containment board. Those not selected will not be able to participate beyond viewing it, but I'm sure a thread will get made on /you/ where people can discuss the happenings in the new forum.
I prefer to cater this forum to as many people as possible, but it is difficult to balance many wants and needs versus coming off as an overbearing janny, and some of the threads that get posted are just outright garbage that are only meant to get (You)s and react bait. Somewhere where old timers and good posters can check each day, without sifting through 20 threads to see something interesting would be a nice addition to the forum I think. Maybe it's just me, but we'll see how it turns out.