- Joined
- Mar 6, 2024
- Messages
- 4,111
Context
If someone wishes for a genie to cut off their little toes with a rusty knife but it misses and also castrates them, is that valid as a corrupted wish? I say yes, because the knife would cut off his little toes and castrate him, thus fulfilling the wish but also corrupting it because he doesn't want to be castrated. However, @Stephen claims I did not grant his wish because the wish wasn't to castrate him.
If someone wishes for a genie to cut off their little toes with a rusty knife but it misses and also castrates them, is that valid as a corrupted wish? I say yes, because the knife would cut off his little toes and castrate him, thus fulfilling the wish but also corrupting it because he doesn't want to be castrated. However, @Stephen claims I did not grant his wish because the wish wasn't to castrate him.