I think it's scary because he's not supposed to be there (singleplayer world)
shit I'd be scared of timmygaming3321 if he suddenly appeared in my world
He used to scare the shit out of me. I thought he was an actual demon that would skullrape me irl if i ever saw him in game.
Yet somehow the idea of getting skullraped by a demon wasn't enough to stop me from playing minecraft.
Not really. He would only be scary if xhe was real, even then just turn off the computer if he appears bro. That's the reason I can't take vidya creepypasta seriously